Most individual tourneys have a registration fee or cost per ticket associated with playing in that tourney. The fees are often either a) given entirely back to participants as cash prizes, or b) split based on some fixed charge or percentage between the players and the venue/house/TDs, organizers to cover costs etc. (Running a tourney, even at your home, is NOT FREE)
Since every IFPA tourney in the state is counting toward the SCS anyway, what IFPA is proposing is that each individual event held contribute $1/player to the SCS and National tourneys with there being a 75%/25% split between the States and Nationals. This will of course create a larger prize fund for the players to compete for when participating at the highest level.
As a comparison: winning the State title in any state yields a prize of $100. To those who actually play frequently in tournaments, they know there have been 3 strikes tourneys and backyard BBQ events held in an afternoon all over the USA that have paid more out than playing for the State Championship title.
I feel that what IFPA is trying to convey is that to qualify and make it to top 16 in the State takes a lot of work and to win the State title even more work. To those who commit to playing all year long trying to qualify for the SCS, it could easily be argued that there should be some prestige/money associated with that greater than $100.
(BTW has anyone noticed Pinburgh pays significantly more to the first place finisher than the PAPA World Championship?)
To those who are against the concept of paying the extra dollar-it is not required unless you want the WPPR points. Nothing is stopping anyone from having tourneys "just for fun" with your friends. Create your own prize fund, and the players can keep it all. Feel free to have tourneys with no fees or cash prizes. Have fun in your leagues or clubs. The tourney just won't get WPPR points. It will be easy to see who wants to compete toward the SCS versus just local bragging rights. The players will give feedback.
I feel what IFPA is trying to do is push competitive pinball into more of the public spotlight and making it appealing to more than the handful of us pinball diehards who follow all of the tournament threads and watch the streams on twitch.